Five Christmas Historical Romances I Love & Five I Want to Read

Posted December 2, 2024 by Jana in Top Ten Tuesday / 24 Comments

Happy December, and welcome to another TTT! I think I’ve drilled it into your head at this point, but I love Christmas. A lot. That’s why the first TTT in December is always a freebie topic. I want to have a super festive topic, but since not everyone celebrates Christmas or loves it as much as I do, I don’t want to make it a topic everyone does. So take this week to write about a topic you love! I love Christmas historical romances a lot. I honestly think they’re my favorite Christmas romances to read. I find them to be so cozy and festive. Today I’m sharing some of my favorites, and some I hope to read this month! I’m excited to see what topic you choose to write about today!

Five Christmas Historical Romances I Love

Marian’s Christmas Wish by Carla Kelly
A Wallflower Christmas by Lisa Kleypas
When She Was Naughty by Tessa Dare
How the Dukes Stole Christmas by Tessa Dare, Sarah MacLean, Sophie Jordan, & Joanna Shupe
Yule Be My Duke by Darcy Burke

Five Christmas Historical Romances I Want to Read This Year

‘Twas the Night Before Scandal by Merry Farmer
The Winter Duke by Jillian Eaton
The Two Bells of Christmas by Joanna Barker
target=”_blank”>Penny’s Yuletide Wish by Sally Britton
Secrets at Selwyn Castle by Anne Rollins

Do you have any recommendations for historical Christmas romances? I can never find enough!

Share this post:

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

24 responses to “Five Christmas Historical Romances I Love & Five I Want to Read

    • Jana

      Oh my gosh, that is a very hard question. LOL. Let me give you a list of my favorites (my favorite favorite is at the top). I adore all of these!

      Contemporary:
      Christmas at Frozen Falls by Kiley Dunbar (Lapland, northern lights, husky puppies, so much swoon, all the snow.)
      Starry Night by Debbie Macomber (Alaska, sexy broody reclusive author, cute dog)
      Snowflakes at the Little Christmas Tree Farm by Jaimie Admans (the cutest tree farm ever, very cozy)
      The Twelve Dates of Christmas by Jenny Bayliss (delightfully British, and one of my favorite audios ever)
      Lovelight Farms by B.K. Borison (a MUST)
      Holiday Romance by Catherine Walsh (acquaintances on a plane to friends on a plane as they travel home for Christmas on the same flight every year. And then they turn to lovers when they get stranded!)
      Faking Christmas by Cindy Steele (sooooo swoony, no spice)
      The Christmas Dress by Courtney Cole (so sweet and lovely that it made me ache)

      Historical:
      A Wallflower Christmas by Lisa Kleypas
      When She Was Naughty by Tessa Dare (one of my favorite novellas ever)
      A Holiday by Gaslight by Mimi Matthews (if you loved Richard Armitage in North & South, this is your book)

      There’s a start! lol. I have many more where these came from!

  1. I haven’t read any of these, but have seen Joanna Barker show up when I browse Amazon or Goodreads. :) Hope you enjoy all of your anticipated choices!

  2. I love the build up to Christmas! I try to make it as magical for the kids as possible, but with the over excitement we can only have soft things on the tree…

    I haven’t read a Historical Christmas Romance before. I might have to give it a try at some point!

    Have a lovely week!

    • Jana

      You sound like me, but I have cats instead of kids. LOL. They love Christmas!!

      Historical Christmas romances are just so, so cozy. I love them more and more as the years go by.

  3. Ooh nice topic and picks! I don’t do much holiday reading myself. It seems my favorite authors rarely write a holiday novel. If a holiday happens to occur in the story, it’s not a central focus point. It’s just there and done. I did read a collection or two of short stories/novellas that were holiday related. That was years ago though. I think the latest short story collections I want to read involve dark fairy tale spins, so still no holidays! Lol. I went with an easy route this week even though it didn’t have to be holiday related, I wanted to get as close as possible to them! Lol.

    Here’s my Tuesday Post

    Have a GREAT day!

    Old Follower :)

    • Jana

      It’s all Christmas books for me, all the time from November 1 through New Year’s Eve! I’ve been spoiled by my favorite authors with many great Christmas books, but I also go hunting for stories regardless of the author and have found some new favorites that way, too! I like your red and green list this week! I’m always a fan of festive topics. :)

  4. Holiday romances are almost a tie with Amish romance as my favorite to read. They are only falling slightly behind.

    A Wallflower Christmas is a wonderful book. I also really enjoyed How the Dukes Stole Christmas. I haven’t read any historical romance lately so no recommendations.

  5. The Mistletoe Countess by Pepper Basham is a historical fiction romance, that I love. I have not read Under the Texas Mistletoe by Karen Witemeyer yet, but hope to this year, it’s also historical fiction. One more, A Christmas Courtship by Shelley Shepard Gray…I am with you, there are not a ton of Historical fiction reads…

    • Jana

      The Mistletoe Countess is super cheap on Audible right now (less than $4), so I just bought it based on your recommendation! I can’t wait to read it! It sounds lovely. I’m adding A Christmas Courtship to my wish list right now! It sounds perfect! Thank you for the recommendations! I hope you enjoy some happy Christmas reading this year. :)

  6. I don’t read a ton of romance or historical romance, but last year a friend told me about these Christmas regency romance collections she always read at Christmas and I decided to pick up one of the collections. I thought I’d hate them because — again — I don’t read a ton of romance (more mysteries) but I ended up feeling so cozy while reading them! I only made it through the first two novellas before Christmas came and got distracted with another mystery so this year I am reading the other three novellas in the collection. Carla Kelley wrote one of the novellas but I haven’t reached that one yet. It’s the last one in the book.

    I hope you enjoy a couple of the ones you want to read this year.

    • Jana

      Thank you, I hope you enjoy your novellas! I’d love to know the title of the collection you’re reading! I love regency romance collections, especially Christmas ones, because it’s nice to have smaller, bite-sized stories during the holidays when I don’t always have much time to read!

      • It is called Regency Christmas Wishes and it has a photo of a woman knocking on a door on it. I found it on Thriftbooks. It looks like there is another version out now with a couple on the front. I think a few of the author’s republished it but looks like a couple of the other novellas got dropped.